Comparing media

One of the biggest news stories in the world of sports is the issues involving the University of Tennessee Athletics.

Eight unnamed women have filed Title X sexual assault cases on the university, stating that the school has permitted a sexually hostile culture to take place on campus.

I’ve watched and heard about the story on multiple news outlets and it seems each has a different approach.

In the articles I’ve read the reporters have been somewhat accusatory in their writing.

CNN for example, has done a very good job getting their research in order and making sure they have the right quotes for the victim’s side.

However, they don’t seem to be digging too deep into the other side of the issue.

There’s very little detail on the credibility of the claims that have been made against the university.  

In one particular article, they don’t present the counter argument until the article is three-fourths done.

I feel by then my opinion on the situation has already been set.

On TV things are a little different, with multiple interviews being shown on the issue, both sides have been able to properly defend themselves.

Former employees and players from the University of Tennessee have been interviewed and have lamented the actions of those leading the school.

While former and present university officials and coaches have been able to give their thoughts on the matter and have brought balance to the issue.

Also with TV, you get to bring in multiple reporters who cover all angles of the story and see what opinions they developed based on their research.

Then lastly you get to radio which is easily the most bias of the three. Especially in sports talk radio, a host will usually find a quote or section of the story that supports their argument.

Then in defense of their side of the argument, sports hosts will find whatever holes they can in the opposing side to discredit them.

For this Tennessee story in particular, I’ve seen radio shows use certain isolated quotes or sound bites that can manipulate the listener’s opinion.

I will give credit however to the 710 ESPN LA station I listen to. The hosts of the shows have been able to give multiple perspectives on the matter due to their mix of journalist and former athletes in studio.

Overall all three forms of media have their pros and cons. When it comes to this story specifically it also depends what network or publications you’re getting the information from.

One could be leaning either way which makes things a little more difficult.